The band itself was pretty good. Their sound was tightly controlled: the lead guitarist's notes were crisp, clean, and dominant, the bass grooved with a warm elasticity, Jenny Lewis' voice was flawless, full, and oozed with...well Jenny Lewisness.The problem? The crowd. Never have I felt my appreciation for a live show be so diminished by the crowd. There was nothing wrong with the crowd in particular...there were the skinny jeaners,
the hipster hairs
the studded belts
and the skinny jeans with studded belts
...fine. They're everywhere. The real issue is that when you go to a concert attended by these folks, the concerts have no life. Sure there is clapping and yelling after each song ends, as if on command...but there's no dancing. There's no movement. There's no energy. The band plays a slow song: The crowd stands there and watches. The band plays a fast song: The crowd stands there and watches. The band plays a dance number: The crowd stands there and watches. The lead singer claps to get the crowd clapping: A few clap, and critical mass point 1 is reached so that many are clapping, but with a slight increase to critical mass point 2, some people will never start clapping because doing so would make them seem like lame late adopters, and then if you keep clapping, there's fear of being the guy who claps too long.
I can't say what it is...but here's my theory. 1) This is a suburban white people phenomenon. 2) It stems from a well-cultivated perception of "irony." 3) It is borne of self-consciousness and fear of what people think of them. Of course, other people just don't have any interest in being remotely active during a concert...which is fine...but I don't really see this widespread phenomenon at...say...Bjork, Pumpkins, or other shows...just the indie rockers.
In any case, people can do whatever they want. I don't think there's any particular way people should behave at concerts, and I don't necessarily think people should dance or thrash or whatever...it just sorta seems like large crowds of people joined by shared interests and passions should result in something bigger, more energetic, and more fun...not less.





